Monday, January 16, 2012

Picture Of Lost Civilization In The Amazon Emerging

The Amazon is home to more groups of uncontacted hunter-gatherers than anyplace else in the world, with the possible exception of Papua New Guinea. But, it isn't generally known as a center of pre-Columbian advanced civilizations comparable to that of the Aztecs of Mesoamerica and the Incas of the Pacific Coast of South America. The only real traces found among contemporary Amazonians of a possible lost civilization are a few legends and some very geographically broad linguistic groupings that don't fit the usual geographically confined hunter-gatherer mold.

But, new pieces of evidence increasingly show signs of a civilization that did greatly modify its environment in the Amazon.

Alceu Ranzi, a Brazilian scholar who helped discover the squares, octagons, circles, rectangles and ovals that make up the land carvings, said these geoglyphs found on deforested land were as significant as the famous Nazca lines, the enigmatic animal symbols visible from the air in southern Peru. . . . parts of the Amazon may have been home for centuries to large populations numbering well into the thousands and living in dozens of towns connected by road networks, explains the American writer Charles C. Mann. In fact, according to Mr. Mann, the British explorer Percy Fawcett vanished on his 1925 quest to find the lost “City of Z” in the Xingu, one area with such urban settlements. . . . So far, 290 such earthworks have been found in Acre, along with about 70 others in Bolivia and 30 in the Brazilian states of Amazonas and Rondônia.

Researchers first viewed the geoglyphs in the 1970s, after Brazil’s military dictatorship encouraged settlers to move to Acre and other parts of the Amazon, using the nationalist slogan “occupy to avoid surrendering” to justify the settlement that resulted in deforestation.

But little scientific attention was paid to the discovery until Mr. Ranzi, the Brazilian scientist, began his surveys in the late 1990s, and Brazilian, Finnish and American researchers began finding more geoglyphs by using high-resolution satellite imagery and small planes to fly over the Amazon.

Denise Schaan, an archaeologist at the Federal University of Pará in Brazil who now leads research on the geoglyphs, said radiocarbon testing indicated that they were built 1,000 to 2,000 years ago, and might have been rebuilt several times during that period. . . . So far, 290 such earthworks have been found in Acre, along with about 70 others in Bolivia and 30 in the Brazilian states of Amazonas and Rondônia.

Researchers first viewed the geoglyphs in the 1970s, after Brazil’s military dictatorship encouraged settlers to move to Acre and other parts of the Amazon, using the nationalist slogan “occupy to avoid surrendering” to justify the settlement that resulted in deforestation. But little scientific attention was paid to the discovery until Mr. Ranzi, the Brazilian scientist, began his surveys in the late 1990s, and Brazilian, Finnish and American researchers began finding more geoglyphs by using high-resolution satellite imagery and small planes to fly over the Amazon.

Denise Schaan, an archaeologist at the Federal University of Pará in Brazil who now leads research on the geoglyphs, said radiocarbon testing indicated that they were built 1,000 to 2,000 years ago, and might have been rebuilt several times during that period. Researchers now believe that the geoglyphs may have held ceremonial importance, similar, perhaps, to the medieval cathedrals in Europe. This spiritual role, said William Balée, an anthropologist at Tulane University, could have been one that involved “geometry and gigantism.”

In 2008, National Geographic reported on a somewhat similarly developed civilization in a part of the Amazon remote from these geoglyphs.

Dozens of ancient, densely packed, towns, villages, and hamlets arranged in an organized pattern have been mapped in the Brazilian Amazon. . . . In 1993, Heckenberger lived with the Kuikuro near the headwaters of the Xingu River. Within two weeks of his stay, he learned about the ancient settlements and began a 15-year effort to study and map them in detail.

So far he has identified at least two major clusters—or polities—of towns, villages, and hamlets. Each cluster contains a central seat of ritualistic power with wide roads radiating out to other communities.

Each settlement is organized around a central plaza and linked to others via precisely placed roads. In their heyday, some of the settlements were home to perhaps thousands of people and were about 150 acres (61 hectares) in size.

A major road aligned with the summer solstice intersects each central plaza.
The larger towns, placed at cardinal points from the central seat of power, were walled much like a medieval town, noted Heckenberger. Smaller villages and hamlets were less well defined.

Between the settlements, which today are almost completely overgrown, was a patchwork of agricultural fields for crops such as manioc along with dams and ponds likely used for fish farms.

"The whole landscape is almost like a latticework, the way it is gridded off," Heckenberger said. "The individual centers themselves are much less constructed. It is more patterned at the regional level."

At their height between A.D. 1250 and 1650, the clusters may have housed around 50,000 people, the scientists noted.

According to Heckenberger, the planned structure of these settlements is indicative of the regional planning and political organization that are hallmarks of urban society.

"These are far more planned at the regional level than your average medieval town," he said, noting that rural landscapes in medieval settlements were randomly oriented.

"Here things are oriented at the same angles and distances across the entire landscape."

Charles C. Mann, in his book 1491, argued that these civilizations collapsed because they came into contact with old world diseases despite limited direct contact with Europeans, and that there was a rewilding of the Americans in response to this population collapse.

This is a possibility that shouldn't be ruled out. But, I'm not necessarily sold on that as the only possible cause, because we have other examples of relatively advanced societies like the irrigation agriculture based societies of the Four Corners area of Colorado that rose and fell due to climate conditions in the Pre-Columbian era, and civilizations like the Mayans and Olmecs that preceded the Aztecs that were interrupted by successor civilizations that were more successful. We have have old world examples like the Harappans of the Indus River Valley and the Western Roman Empire, who apparently managed to experience the collapse of their societies without the assistance of an influx of superlethal Old World diseases.

Still, clearly these civilization did collapse, and clearly they did have some level of urban organization and agriculture in the pre-Columbian era in the Amazon.

2 comments:

Alejandro Rivero said...

I like your anthropology links too :-)

Have you done, or plan to do, some series about Gell-Mann institution work on language evolution?

Andrew Oh-Willeke said...

I've did a lengthly post at my non-science blog (Wash Park Prophet) before I split Dispatches From Turtle Island off as a separate blog on a paper he did on the Altaic languages, which made some interesting points but was poorly done and greatly overstated his conclusions. I think I've done a post somewhere since then on another one of his papers that was rather bad and have seen some writings about his recent work.

He has basically two problems. One is that he is too wedded to some over the top ideas from the Russian school of linguistics which has ill supported ideas like the Nostradic and Sino-Caucasian language families. The other is that his application of mathematical models to linguistics fails to account for enough assumptions and linguistic details that we know from other sources. I can sympathize with the sentiment he has of wanting to do the work, but his lack of knowledge base in linguistics shows.